A review of CreditKarma

Written by Alex

Topics: General

First 4 digits of a credit card
Image via Wikipedia

I just came across an interesting site called CreditKarma, thanks to a close friend of mine.  It’s been around for a few years, but I hadn’t yet heard about it. It offers to provide you with a quick, easy and FREE credit score, unlike other sites which cost money each time you use them.

It sounded a bit fishy at first, mostly because I am skeptical of all services which require me to put in lots of personal information. In the name of science and insane curiosity, I checked it out. Sure enough, it was, indeed, quick, easy and free.

Here’s a snapshot of what the CreditKarma dashboard looks like to a signed in user:

Obviously, it provides some nice graphics and easy to read score analysis.  I also learned a few interesting things about my particular credit score. Your score is more or less based on 7 things:

  1. Open Credit Card Utilization – Having access to credit but not maxing it out is a GOOD thing.
  2. Percent of On Time Payments – Do you pay your creditors back on time?
  3. Average Age of Credit Lines – Having an older credit line shows creditors that you’ve got good history.
  4. Total Accounts – More people willing to give you credit is seen as a good thing (I think this is nuts, but more later)
  5. Hard Credit Inquiries – The number of times new creditors ask for your credit score. More can be seen as a warning sign that you’ve been scrounging for cash from a lot of different people. “Soft” scores like requests made on your behalf are not counted.
  6. Total Debt – Obviously, tons of debt is not a good thing.
  7. Debt to Income Ratio – Do you make enough money to cover your interest payments?

One of the crazier things to me was the number of accounts opened. I received an “F” rating in this category due to my measly 3 credit accounts (1 credit card, and 2 debit cards…I avoid debt like the plague). Apparently, in order to have an “A” rating, I would need to have over 40 different accounts opened. This is INSANE, and I will never ever ever do this. Nor should you!

Moral of the story is check out your credit score. If you find something a little odd, make sure to go to the Annual Credit Report Agency.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Blogplay
  • klin
    Alex, thanks for the review of our site. To be clear on the number of accounts, it is not debt that is important for a good credit score but the experience of managing credit accounts. You shouldn't rush out and open accounts just to boost your credit score but you should know that more experience is better perceived by lenders.
  • Thanks for your comments Kenneth. You are the CEO of CreditKarma,
    correct? Also, did I understand your analysis correctly when it showed
    that to receive an A rating, one would need over 40 credit accounts?

    Thanks again!
  • Nice review, Alex. Heard about this through Chris Maury. As I mentioned a few days ago, it's so interesting how skewed the incentives are for someone trying to be financially responsible. Why should one's open accounts be weighted so heavily in the credit score algorithm? If only your score of "F" (for 3 credit cards!) stood for "frickin' fantastic..."
  • Thanks, Alan. I know you've signed up for the service. What have been
    your takeaways?
blog comments powered by Disqus